Is It Trading or Is It Gambling?

Boris Schlossberg

Can the New York Times be any more condescending in its coverage of the latest “outrage” of the week — the phony scandals in the two sports based fantasy websites in US. Suddenly just like Claude Raines in Casablanca they are “Shocked! Shocked! that gambling is going on here.” casablanca

Except that it’s not.

In this video the “paper of record” can barely hold back its distaste for the whole sordid enterprise of fantasy sports even as it interviews one of its most successful practitioners — a college student from DePauw University who has made hundreds of thousands of dollars betting on sports events.

He patiently explains to the reporter how he diversifies his bets, optimizes his player picks and constantly re-evaluates his line ups. In other words, he is doing everything that a successful prop trader would do. Yet the Times can’t help but smirk at the volatility of his returns as “evidence” of gambling.

This is wrong on so many levels because it is the same ill-informed insult casually tossed at anyone who tries to speculate in the financial markets. “Aren’t you JUST gambling?” is question I get all the time typically usually wrapped in a smarmy smile and a look of pity.

No moron. I am not.

sports-bettingGambling is a fixed odds system in which the participant is guaranteed to lose against the house. So in blackjack, craps, baccarat, roulette the odds are always at least 50.5% to 49.5% against you.

That means that no matter how much money you have if you play long enough you will lose it ALL. There is absolutely no doubt about that and the critical point to understand is that all casino games are FIXED odds structures which is why you should never play them.

Now the moment you change those rules, the moment for example, you start counting cards at blackjack, you no longer have a fixed odds system and you actually have a dynamic market in which skill can win. That’s why casinos hate card counters and ban them the moment they spot them. Casinos love the create the “illusion” of a market but their game is very clearly and very deeply rigged.

Everything else in life is just a market with open ended — and more importantly — dynamically changing odds of success.

Is walking against a red light in front of my house on Broadway gambling? For that matter is walking against a green light gambling too? Well at 4 AM in the morning when the road is barren the answer is pretty much no. But at 4 PM in the daytime when some tourist from Jersey doesn’t know that there is no right on red in New York and decides to swerve a Chevy Tahoe in your face — well then the answer is yes.

Master the Basics of Currency Trading

Our new online currency trading course is now LIVE!  Now you can master the basics of currency trading in 5 easy lessons.

You’ll discover…

  • How the currency market works:  A basic primer and description of the world’s 8 major currencies and how to trade them—simply and easily
  • How currencies can make you BIG money whether the stock market is rising or falling
  • How to speak the currency trader’s “language” to master all the terminology you’ll need to succeed
  • How to successfully invest in currencies using plain English “Buy” and “Sell” signals that are so easy to read and understand, a child could follow them

And much, much more.

PLUS, you also get lifetime access to the videos and course materials including workbooks and transcripts for all 5 modules!

Click here to learn more.

My point is that it its incredibly incorrect to refer all betting activities as gambling without understanding the underlying structure of the game. Otherwise everything we do in life, from what we put in our mouth, how we choose to make money, to what person we decide to marry is “gambling”.

When that’s not the case.

It is the assumption of risk, but it is not a guarantee that you will lose like in Vegas.

So the proper question to ask when it comes to trading isn’t — are you gambling or not? — but rather are you able to successfully manage the risk of the market or not.images

To put it bluntly if you suck and are losing all your money you are probably gambling in the worst sense of the word — i.e. guessing wildly without any understanding of the probabilities involved. If on the other hand you are seeing steady and consistent success — you may be actually skillful.

The key to understanding if you are lucky versus good, rests on the number of tries. This actually makes eminent sense when you bring it back to sports. Anyone can sink a 10-foot putt, but do it 1000 times and I guarantee you that Jordan Spieth and Jason Day will beat you every time. The general rule in life that separates luck and skill is the ability to replicate success over a large sample size.golf bets

Although statisticians will tell you that 100-200 samples is usually good enough, when it comes to trading I think you need at least 1000 trades to have some degree of confidence that what you are doing is more than luck. My latest day trading system for example has done 1618 trades made 30.29% with a drawdown of 18.60%.

All pretty good stats, but hardly enough to make me want to put it on auto pilot and retire to Florida. In fact, I don’t think I will ever do that because as I said earlier markets are open ended probability systems that require constant adjustment which means I’ll probably be tweaking my strategies till the day I die.

So am I gambling when I am trading?

No.

I am WORKING on my ideas every single day — just like everybody else

Until next time,

Boris Schlossberg

Mr. Schlossberg is  the managing partner at BKForex  and creator of the new course The ULTIMATE Forex Trading Course produced in conjunction with Weiss Educational Services. He is also a weekly contributor to CNBC’s Squawk Box and a regular commentator for CNBC Asia and CNBC Europe. His daily currency research is quoted by Reuters, Dow Jones, Bloomberg and Agence France Presse newswires and appears in numerous business publications and newspapers worldwide. Mr. Schlossberg has written articles on trading for SFO magazine, Active Trader and Technical Analysis of Stocks and Commodities. He is the author of Technical Analysis of the Currency Market and Millionaire Traders: How Everyday People Beat Wall Street at its Own Game, both of which are published by Wiley. Boris’ extensive experience in trading and developing momentum based techniques provide the foundation for BKForex strategies. 

1a